Yankees Face Offseason Battle to Retain Cody Bellinger Amid $165 Million Projections

article image source: empiresportsmedia.com (link)

Cody Bellinger’s resurgence in New York has made him one of baseball’s most sought-after free agents. As the Yankees prepare for a critical offseason, the team’s determination to re-sign their star outfielder could define the future of their championship hopes.

Yankees Prepare for a Crucial Winter

The New York Yankees are entering an offseason filled with difficult decisions and high expectations. After another year of falling short of the World Series, General Manager Brian Cashman faces pressure to retool the roster without losing key contributors. At the center of that challenge stands Cody Bellinger, whose breakout 2025 season has reignited both his career and the Yankees’ belief in him as a cornerstone player.

At 30 years old, Bellinger has once again proven why he was once among baseball’s brightest stars. His combination of power, athleticism, and defensive versatility made him an invaluable part of the Yankees’ lineup. Following his standout year, he opted out of the final $25 million of his contract to test free agency — but New York has already made clear that bringing him back is a top priority.

Cody Bellinger Free Agency: Return to Dodgers?

A Season of Resurgence

Bellinger’s 2025 campaign marked one of the best of his career since his 2019 MVP season. Over 151 games, he produced a .272/.334/.480 slash line with 29 home runs, 98 RBIs, and 12 stolen bases. His 5.1 bWAR ranked second-highest of his career, highlighting his complete return to form after several inconsistent seasons.

Beyond his offensive resurgence, Bellinger’s glove was just as valuable. Logging nearly 1,300 innings in the outfield, he tallied 12 defensive runs saved and six outs above average, demonstrating elite range and reliability. His ability to seamlessly transition between center, right, and left field gives the Yankees rare lineup flexibility — a quality few teams can replicate.

His swing, perfectly suited for Yankee Stadium’s short right-field porch, remains one of the organization’s key reasons for wanting to keep him. Simply put, Bellinger’s skillset fits the Yankees like a glove.

The Market Heats Up

With such a strong campaign behind him, Bellinger’s market value has skyrocketed. ESPN’s Kiley McDaniel recently projected a six-year, $165 million deal — averaging $27.5 million annually. For the Yankees, that’s a major financial commitment, but one they may find hard to avoid.

Rival teams are already circling. The Los Angeles Dodgers, who drafted and developed Bellinger, are rumored to be interested in a reunion. The New York Mets, eager to close the gap on their crosstown rivals, are also reportedly in the mix. Both franchises have the financial power to push the bidding into uncomfortable territory for the Yankees.

For an organization already operating above the luxury tax threshold, every dollar counts. Yet, letting Bellinger walk could create a hole nearly impossible to fill — both statistically and symbolically. As one MLB executive told NJ.com, the Yankees are expected to pursue Bellinger “regardless of what happens with the rest of the outfield.”

Alternatives and What’s at Stake

If Bellinger were to sign elsewhere, the Yankees’ options shrink quickly. Houston Astros star Kyle Tucker is one name floated as a potential alternative, but his expected $300 million-plus price tag could make him unattainable. Few other players on the market offer Bellinger’s combination of left-handed power, defensive excellence, and proven ability to perform in a big-market spotlight.

For New York, re-signing Bellinger isn’t just a preference — it’s a necessity. His presence balances the lineup, strengthens the defense, and brings the kind of energy and professionalism the Yankees have long sought to recapture.

Looking Ahead: The Heart of the Bronx

As the Yankees prepare for 2026, the outcome of the Bellinger negotiations could define their trajectory. Bringing back Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton, and Gerrit Cole provides a foundation, but keeping Bellinger cements their core and keeps the championship window open.

Bellinger’s story — from former MVP, through years of struggle, to rediscovering his form in the Bronx — is one of persistence and rebirth. For a franchise built on comebacks and legacies, his return could symbolize a new chapter of hope.

Whether the Yankees can fend off their deep-pocketed rivals remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: Cody Bellinger has once again become the player everyone wants — and the one the Yankees can’t afford to lose.

Sources: